Book Club: A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius by Dave Eggers – Book Review

I didn’t know what to expect going into this book because it was categorized as a memoir and fiction. My mind couldn’t really wrap around that concept, but looking into it more, I realized that rather than the traditional chronological autobiography, the book uses an erratic, hyper-aware, and theatrical voice that tends to feel more like a fictional novel.

With that being said, I gave the book 2.75 stars out of 5. This book is a 2000 memoir by Dave Eggers that chronicles his life in his early twenties when he becomes the primary caretaker for his eight-year-old brother, Toph, after both of their parents die from cancer within weeks of each other. 

The beginning was extremely sad and hard to get through at times. I appreciated how Eggers made fun of the cancer being a city and telling the doctor to turn off the light. It felt so real like you want to turn it into something you understand.

Some of the tangents he went on got hard to follow sometimes and part of it was how the narrator read the book. The narrator did an amazing job capturing the cocky voice of Eggers, so much so that I felt like Eggers was actually reading his own story.

The interview with MTV was so awkward. It was an interesting way of using The Real World to tell the story in that part of the book, but I found myself tuning out sometimes.

I liked when they moved to San Francisco. I started to feel as though the ending was coming, but he went on to Chicago. It started to feel long to me. When the book was over, I didn’t understand why Eggers needed to tell people how to read it in the epilogue or what should’ve been the prologue.

I guess I’m old fashioned, but memoir and fiction don’t go together for me. Wanting his book to be taught in classrooms for years to come felt cocky; like he’s expecting everyone to enjoy this book like it’s some epic everyone needs to pick up.

I appreciate him wanting to tell his story and I understand that it’s a very sad thing to lose both parents, but trying to make the book come across as fiction made it seem as though he was trying to cover up feelings he didn’t really know how to convey.

On Goodreads it says, “A book that redefines both family and narrative for the twenty-first century. A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius is the moving memoir of a college senior who, in the space of five weeks, loses both of his parents to cancer and inherits his eight-year-old brother.

Here is an exhilarating debut that manages to be simultaneously hilarious and wildly inventive as well as a deeply heartfelt story of the love that holds a family together.”

I’m still confused by the “wildly inventive” part because I thought it was a memoir. This book does show its age, but nothing can be fictionalized about the sadness of loved ones passing away.

Leave a Reply